John Rizvi

patent vs trade secret

Secrets can pick interest and anxiety at once. The case of patent vs trade secret is the same. You must know about them to protect your intellectual property, as they mean good security for yourself and your original ideas.

Patent vs Trade Secret: Which One is the Best Choice?

The fact that you are here means you need clarity between patent vs trade secret protection. Both these rights have strengths and weaknesses for your technology or product. The best option will boil down to the property type you want to protect.

Patent Protection

Pay attention to what a patent protects. A patent gives the patent holder the right to prohibit others from making or using or selling all under the scope of the patent.

Patent protection allows you complete control over the technology or product. It is the legal shield to kick others out of the market and fully own your invention.

Patents last 15 years for design patents and 20 years for utility patents. They demand that you file a patent application with the United States Patent and Trademark Office. The application should have a thorough detail of what you are trying to obtain rights over. It is a comprehensive process, so be prepared beforehand.

The Uniform Trade Secrets Act defines a trade secret as “information, including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device, method, technique, or process that derives independent economic value by remaining unknown.”

You can tell what classifies as a trade secret under this definition. It must:

  • Be information with actual or potential economic value with the ability of being unknown.
  • Have value to others who cannot get their hands on this information.
  • Be subject to special measures to maintain its secrecy.

Google’s search algorithm and the Coca-Cola recipe are the finest examples of a trade secret. Their main value lies in the fact that their secret is safe and not known in the market.

This is the main patent and trade secret difference. Now you know a lot on the subject matter of trade secret vs patent. Next, we discuss the advantages of trade secrets.

The Advantages of Trade Secrets

We have already discussed the importance and advantages of patents in our other articles. Let us focus on trade secrets for now. Trade secret protection has some strong advantages. You could use them instead of going for patent protection. 

1. Secrecy Keeps Your Invention Safe

If you have to keep the entire mechanism of your invention secret, then you should opt for trade secret protection. It is important to understand that you must protect your key element to qualify for protection under trade secret law. Protect your trade secret well.

Keep the exposure minimum so that your trade secret is secure. Create safety measures, such as a non-disclosure agreement, to maximize your protection.

2. Advantageous When Your Work is not Patentable

The option of trade secrets works best when what you want to protect does not qualify for a patent. Some of the trade secrets are not patentable as they are not particularly inventive or do not cover all that is needed to be a patent. The path of a trade secret is what you walk on in such a case.

3. Cheaper than Patent Protection

Patent application costs are a lot higher compared to trade secrets. You have to consider patent search fees, patent filing fees, and an attorney’s fees to get a hand on a patent.

No filings are needed for qualification of trade secret protection. Law continues to protect a secret as long as the holder implements best practices to keep the secret a secret. 

4. Better Longevity

Trade secrets are simply better for longevity. Trade secrets never expire. You can enjoy an indefinite period of protection as long as your secret is not exposed to the public eye.

Patents expire in 20 years. That is possibly the only downfall of longevity that could make you consider trade secrets instead. You may prefer a trade secret now.

Conclusion

Patent vs trade secret should not be a competition. Both have their significance as they are used to protect your intellectual property rights in their own domains. It is crucial to know the factors of both so that you can reach the right decision. You may consult a professional intellectual property attorney like John Rhizvi to help you learn which option suits you best.

FAQ

A patent reveals an invention and allows exclusive legal rights for a specific amount of time. A trade secret keeps key information hidden and protects it as long as it remains secret.

You cannot patent a trade secret. A patented item is no secret because patent law requires public disclosure.

A trade secret must be valuable to others, hold economic value, and reasonably protected to keep the secret safe.

No. Trade secrets are easier to obtain because they require no filing process. Maintaining secrecy can still be challenging and requires proper protection measures.

Yes. Not for the same information. You can patent some aspects and keep other components secret if they are separate and still protectable.

The information must have economic value. It must not be known to the general public. It must be protected through confidentiality measures such as NDAs or restricted access.